Skip to main content

The Asymmetry of Information

By December 24, 2021March 30th, 2025Bloggers, Parker4 min read

Normally, I would not rave about an article in the New York Times (NYT), but I was gripped by the commentary of Peter Coy, a columnist who is active in a writers’ group that I belong to- the New York Financial Writers Association (NYFWA). Like so many other groups, we stopped our in-person gatherings abruptly in early 2020, and have been meeting virtually since then. The bad news- the in person camaraderie is missing, but the virtual venue has expanded the organization’s reach beyond the local area for both attendees and speakers alike.

In many economic articles, including a few by NYFWA members, there have been statements along the lines of “Data is the new oil,” or similar, which makes sense when considering that  companies  trading in information continue to move up in the rankings, while natural resources giants- the same guys chartering tankers and bulkers,  have slid down in the rankings. In Mr. Coy’s NYT  article, Why It’s Easier Than Ever to Buy a Used Car, he covered small bits of automotive nostalgia, but mostly focused on the value of information. In a nutshell, he describes a market that was previously (a few decades back) lop-sided (asymmetrical), with sellers, ie the highly mis-trusted car dealers, having far more information about particular assets than the buyers- who, not surprisingly, backed away from transactions after being stymied. Over time, with tools such as Carfax (which gathers records from now required filings on repairs, accidents, and other items that might previously have remained in the shadows). The end result, fast forwarding from the non-information days of the 1970s up to the 2020s, is that buyers have felt empowered.

My writing concentrates on vessels that float, carrying industrial and commodity cargoes, rather than landside passenger vehicles. But I was led to consider the parallels with maritime, and the implications, if any, for information flow. And, I think that there are some. Shipping, to its credit, has a lengthy history of record keeping on technical matters, like surveys and condition reports, from Class Societies. At one time, S & P brokers would hire records inspectors who, with permission, would pore through paper files at the office of a Class Society. These days actual records reviews, both technical (Class) and at the Registry level, have taken a digital turn, though “pre-sale inspections” of the assets, ie an inspection done before an actual vessel sale, have been integrated into marketing packages. By the way, financiers, who gave us “digital data rooms”, have been known to poke through these files, as well. I read that the maritime insurance folks have come up with their own version of the “Poseidon Principles.” Bring on those trajectories.

As we move on pathways to 2025, 2030, and 2050, we have a whole new wave of abbreviations and acronyms to contend with; much as been written here and elsewhere about EEXI, CII and the rest of them, many tied to items filed with the European Union and/or the International Maritime Organization (IMO). Class Societies will retain their roles as repositories of information, like the approval of a new streamlined propeller, that leads to conformity with EEXI targets. Whole new information providers have sprung up, and existing players have evolved, offering good approximations of CII for vessels, as well as their likely adherence to the aforementioned trajectories.

The buyers, of the actual ships (in S and P transactions) and certainly in the chartering realm, are inching closer to information nirvana with various ratings engines that are out there. There is something to be done here. But, in our maritime realm, we don’t yet have a Carfax.

Leave a Reply

Access is complimentary.
Please log in or register to continue.